labvanced logoLabVanced
Contact
    • Remote Physiological Measurements
    • Eye Tracking
    • Head & Face-Tracking
    • Emotion Detection
    • Heart Rate Detection (rPPG)
    • Generative AI
    • Audio Transcription
    • EEG & Hardware Integrations
    • Decision Making
    • Reaction Times
    • Keyboard Inputs
    • Mouse Tracking
    • Mobile / Touch
    • Questionnaires
    • Gamepad / Joystick Integration
    • Audio Recordings
    • Audio Transcription
    • Video Recordings
    • Screen Recordings
    • Photos / Snapshots
    • Video Conferencing
    • Canvas Drawings
    • Build with AI
    • Build with Spreadsheets
    • Using the Experiment Editor
    • Coding
    • Creating Questionnaires
    • Balancing & Randomization
    • UX & Website Testing
    • Single Session Studies
    • Factorial Designs
    • Longitudinal & Multi-session Studies
    • Individual & Case Studies
    • Real-time Multi-user Studies
    • Interviews & Video Calls
    • Surveys & Questionnaires
    • Experience Sampling & Diaries
    • Classroom & Group Testing
    • Interventions & Clinical Trials
    • In the Browser
    • Mobile App
    • Desktop App
    • WebBridge Chrome Extension
    • Stroop Test
    • Flanker Task
    • N-back Task
    • Implicit Association Test
    • Trail Making Test
    • Digit Span
    • Corsi Block Tapping
    • Tower of London
    • Balloon Analog Risk Task
    • Preferential Looking
    • Browse more →
    • DASS-21
    • GAD-7
    • Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale
    • PHQ-9
    • Ten-Item Personality Inventory
    • Big Five Personality Test
    • Adult ADHD Self-Report Scale
    • Browse more →
    • Building a Multi-user Study
    • Webcam Eye Tracking with AOIs
    • Website Frame Eye Tracking
    • Conditional Eye Tracking Opt-in
    • ChatGPT Study
    • Desktop App Study with EEG
    • Between-subjects Group Balancing
    • Building a Reading Study
    • Stroop Task
    • Lexical Decision Task
    • Browse more →
    Public Experiment Library
    • Arts Research
    • Clinical Psychology & Neuropsychology Medicine
    • Cognitive Psychology
    • Developmental Psychology
    • Behavioral Economics & Decision Science
    • Educational Research & Psychology
    • HCI & Human Factors
    • Linguistics & Language Sciences
    • Consumer & Marketing Research
    • Social & Personality Psychology
    • Sport & Movement Science
    • UX & Website Testing
    • Executive Functions
    • Language & Reading
    • Decision-Making & Reasoning
    • Attention
    • Overview
    • HCI & Human Factors
    • UX & Website Testing
    • Consumer & Marketing Research
    • White-Label App
    • PageGazer
    • Webcam vs. Lab Eye Tracking in InfantsAnna Banki & Gabriela Markova
    • Eye Tracking for Influencer MarketingDr. Alexander Edeling
    • Eye Tracking Infant Word ComprehensionDr. Giulia Calignano
    • Sentence Reading and Grammar JudgmentsDr. Jonathan Mirault
    • Regulating Emotions with MusicDr. Katrin Starcke
    • Game-Based Grammar Learning in ChildrenDr. Mireia Marimon
    • Gaze Cueing and AutismMax Soares Miehstein
    • Personality and Hearing in NoiseDr. Malte Wöstmann
    • All interviews →
    • Lab Notes
    • How to Cite Labvanced
    • Labvanced Platform Paper (2017)
    • Webcam Eye Tracking Validation (2024)
    • Webcam Eye Tracking Studies
    • Cognitive Psychology Studies
    • Developmental Psychology Studies
    • Linguistics Studies
    • See all publications →
    • Getting Started
    • Guide
    • Video Tutorials
    • Walkthroughs
    • Live Chat
    • Webinars & Onboarding Calls
    • AI Assistant
    • FAQ
    • Importing Templates Guide
    • Test Templates
    • Live Eye Tracking Metrics
    • Mouse Tracking Demo
    • ChatGPT Demo
    • Audio Recording Object Demo
    • Adding Image Stimuli Demo
    • Score & Feedback Demo
    • Browse all technical demos →
    • Timing Precision
    • Stimuli Presentation
    • Headphone Checks
    • Bot Checks
    • Participant Management
    • Comparisons
    • Research Blog
    • Prolific Integration
    • CloudResearch Integration
    • Sona Systems Integration
    • BeSample Integration
    • Panelabs Integration
    • Clickworker Integration
    • Labvanced Webhook API
    • Labvanced REST API
    • About Us
    • Newsletter Archive
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Data Security & Data Privacy
    • Technical & Organisational Measures
    • Accessibility
    • W-8BEN-E Form
    • Data Processing Agreement Template
    LinkedInYouTubeDiscord
    • Individual
    • Lab
    • Department / Consortium
    • Teaching
    • Campus
    • Commercial
    • Browse recording top-ups →
    • Browse AI token top-ups →
    • Overview
    • Study Building
    • Subject Recruitment
    • Dedicated Support
    Checkout
  • Contact
    • EN
      • 中國人
      • Deutsch
      • Français
      • Español
      • English
      • 日本語
    • Logout
    • Loginlogin icon
    Platform
    Labvanced makes it easy to implement the most advanced study design and reliably collect your data.
    Biosignals & AI
    Remote Physiological MeasurementsEye TrackingHead & Face-TrackingEmotion DetectionHeart Rate Detection (rPPG)Generative AIAudio TranscriptionEEG & Hardware Integrations
    Behavioral Recordings
    Decision MakingReaction TimesKeyboard InputsMouse TrackingMobile / TouchQuestionnairesGamepad / Joystick Integration
    Media Recordings
    Audio RecordingsAudio TranscriptionVideo RecordingsScreen RecordingsPhotos / SnapshotsVideo ConferencingCanvas Drawings
    Implementation Techniques
    Build with AIBuild with SpreadsheetsUsing the Experiment EditorCodingCreating QuestionnairesBalancing & RandomizationUX & Website Testing
    Study Formats

    Your study can take whatever format your research needs. Here are a few popular examples.

    Single Session StudiesFactorial DesignsLongitudinal & Multi-session StudiesIndividual & Case StudiesReal-time Multi-user StudiesInterviews & Video CallsSurveys & QuestionnairesExperience Sampling & DiariesClassroom & Group TestingInterventions & Clinical Trials
    Where Studies Run

    Run your study online in the browser, on mobile or tablet with the mobile app, or in-lab with the desktop app.

    In the BrowserMobile AppDesktop AppWebBridge Chrome Extension
    Tests
    Explore cognitive tests, questionnaires, walkthroughs, and our public experiment library: a starting point for your next study.
    Popular Cognitive Tests
    Stroop TestFlanker TaskN-back TaskImplicit Association TestTrail Making TestDigit SpanCorsi Block TappingTower of LondonBalloon Analog Risk TaskPreferential Looking
    Browse more →
    Questionnaires & Scales
    DASS-21GAD-7Rosenberg Self-Esteem ScalePHQ-9Ten-Item Personality InventoryBig Five Personality TestAdult ADHD Self-Report Scale
    Browse more →
    Public Experiment Library

    Take a look at what other researchers in the community are doing through our extensive, open catalog of shared studies.

    Open the public library →
    Walkthroughs

    Step-by-step builds of complete studies, from a blank project to a running experiment, that you can follow along or adapt.

    Building a Multi-user StudyWebcam Eye Tracking with AOIsWebsite Frame Eye TrackingConditional Eye Tracking Opt-inChatGPT StudyDesktop App Study with EEGBetween-subjects Group BalancingBuilding a Reading StudyStroop TaskLexical Decision Task
    Browse more →
    Research
    One platform for students, academics, and industry researchers studying human behavior.
    Harvard UniversityStanford UniversityCambridge UniversityUCLNYUMax Planck InstituteUCLATU Munich

    Trusted by researchers at 1,500+ universities worldwide

    Academic Research
    Arts ResearchClinical Psychology & Neuropsychology MedicineCognitive PsychologyDevelopmental PsychologyBehavioral Economics & Decision ScienceEducational Research & PsychologyHCI & Human FactorsLinguistics & Language SciencesConsumer & Marketing ResearchSocial & Personality PsychologySport & Movement ScienceUX & Website Testing
    Research Areas
    Executive FunctionsLanguage & ReadingDecision-Making & ReasoningAttention
    Industry / Commercial
    OverviewHCI & Human FactorsUX & Website TestingConsumer & Marketing ResearchWhite-Label AppPageGazer
    Researcher Interviews

    Conversations with researchers about the studies they ran with Labvanced, what worked, and what they learned.

    Webcam vs. Lab Eye Tracking in InfantsAnna Banki & Gabriela MarkovaEye Tracking for Influencer MarketingDr. Alexander EdelingEye Tracking Infant Word ComprehensionDr. Giulia CalignanoSentence Reading and Grammar JudgmentsDr. Jonathan MiraultRegulating Emotions with MusicDr. Katrin StarckeGame-Based Grammar Learning in ChildrenDr. Mireia MarimonGaze Cueing and AutismMax Soares MiehsteinPersonality and Hearing in NoiseDr. Malte Wöstmann
    All interviews →
    Our Research
    Lab NotesHow to Cite Labvanced
    Peer Reviewed Studies

    A selection of peer-reviewed work built on Labvanced: our own platform and validation papers, and studies by the research community grouped by area. Hundreds more are listed on the full publications page.

    Labvanced Platform Paper (2017)Webcam Eye Tracking Validation (2024)Webcam Eye Tracking StudiesCognitive Psychology StudiesDevelopmental Psychology StudiesLinguistics Studies
    See all publications →
    Resources
    Valuable resources to help you learn the platform, stay updated, and more.
    Documentation
    Getting StartedGuideVideo TutorialsWalkthroughs
    Support
    Live ChatWebinars & Onboarding CallsAI AssistantFAQ
    Templates & Demos

    These are a few popular examples. Browse our guide and a selection of technical demos to get started with implementation.

    Importing Templates GuideTest TemplatesLive Eye Tracking MetricsMouse Tracking DemoChatGPT DemoAudio Recording Object DemoAdding Image Stimuli DemoScore & Feedback Demo
    Browse all technical demos →
    Methodology
    Timing PrecisionStimuli PresentationHeadphone ChecksBot ChecksParticipant ManagementComparisonsResearch Blog
    Integrations & APIs
    Prolific IntegrationCloudResearch IntegrationSona Systems IntegrationBeSample IntegrationPanelabs IntegrationClickworker IntegrationLabvanced Webhook APILabvanced REST API
    Company & Legal
    About UsNewsletter ArchiveTerms & ConditionsData Security & Data PrivacyTechnical & Organisational MeasuresAccessibilityW-8BEN-E FormData Processing Agreement Template
    LinkedInYouTubeDiscord
    Pricing
    Our licenses and additional services at a glance.
    Licenses
    IndividualLabDepartment / ConsortiumTeachingCampusCommercial
    Top-Ups

    Need more recordings for your lab or your own research? Simply use one of these recording top-up packages.

    Browse recording top-ups →

    Need more AI tokens for the AI assistant and study translations? Simply use one of these AI token top-up packages.

    Browse AI token top-ups →
    Additional Services

    Hire Labvanced’s expert team to quickly bring your project to the level of rigor it needs.

    OverviewStudy BuildingSubject RecruitmentDedicated Support
    Checkout

    Ready to purchase a license or top-up? Head straight to checkout.

    Go to checkout →
    • 中國人
    • Deutsch
    • Français
    • Español
    • English
    • 日本語
    Abstract illustration of the mindfulness based self efficacy scale.

    Types of Stimuli in Delay Discounting Tasks

    While hypothetical money is the most common stimulus in delay discounting tasks due to its ease of manipulation and generalizability, researchers employ a wide variety of other stimuli (from food to health outcomes to entertainment and more) to investigate specific behaviors, populations, or real-world decisions.

    Types of stimuli categories used in delay discounting tasks include:

    • Money & Monetary Rewards
    • Primary Reinforcers
          Food
          Drinks / Alcohol
          Drugs of Abuse
          Intercourse
    • Social Interactions
    • Health Outcomes
    • Environmental Outcomes
    • Educational & Career Outcomes
    • Consumer Goods & Experiences

    These can be broadly categorized and are discussed in greater detail below.

    Money and Monetary Rewards

    Money is the commonly used stimuli in delay discounting tasks and is considered an effective stimulus due to several reasons. Research indicates that hypothetical money outcomes are discounted similarly to actual money outcomes, making it a practical and valid stimulus for delay discounting research. Moreover, money is not perishable or subject to satiety effects (Odum et al., 2006; Odum et al., 2020).

    In delay discounting tasks using money as stimuli, participants are typically presented with a smaller immediate amount and a larger delayed amount choices and are expected to choose the two. The presented amounts vary in each trial and usually follow a pattern. For example:

    • Receive $10 today or $11 tomorrow
    • Receive $10 today or $50 in a month

    Try out the delay discounting task or import it to your account.

    Primary Reinforcers

    These are stimuli that are intrinsically rewarding and often have a direct biological or physiological basis. Examples include:

    Food

    Delay discounting tasks that use food as stimuli are relevant in obesity research and are also used in studies assessing eating behavior and even animal models (e.g., a small treat now vs. a larger portion later) (Weygandt, M., et al. 2015). A study noted that food rewards are discounted more steeply than money, making them ecologically valid in obesity-related research (Rasmussen et al., 2024).

    Drinks and Alcohol

    Similar to food, stimuli of drinks are relevant for studies on thirst, alcohol use, etc. For instance, by incorporating alcohol as a reward stimulus in both single-commodity (alcohol offered now or later) and cross-commodity tasks (e.g., alcohol now vs. money later) on individuals who misuse alcohol, it was found that participants showed a stronger preference for immediate alcohol over delayed money and were more willing to wait for alcohol over immediate money (Taylor et al., 2023).

    Drugs of Abuse

    For individuals with substance use disorders, choices between immediate drug access (e.g., one dose now vs. three doses in two days) and delayed drug access or money can reveal very steep discounting specific to that substance. The repeated emphasis on drug-related choices highlights the impulsive nature of decision-making among drug abusers compared to non-abusers (Petry, 2003).

    Intercourse

    Although less common due to ethical and practical considerations, the underlying concept of immediate vs. delayed sexual gratification is relevant. In a study on sexual delay discounting, participants chose between immediate and delayed preference of sex (e.g., sex right now without protection vs. wait 3 hours for sex with protection). (Lawyer, 2008).

    Social Interactions

    In some delay discounting tasks, participants were presented with choices involving hypothetical face-to-face social interactions. The immediate component was speaking face-to-face right now and the delayed component was speaking face-to-face after a delay (e.g., 10 minutes speaking face-to-face with a person right now vs. 25 min speaking face-to-face with the person in 10 months) (Charlton et al., 2012).

    Online Likes and Followers

    Increasingly relevant in digital contexts, is studying how participants value online-related rewards such as likes or follows.

    A study used hypothetical Instagram followers and likes in a delay discounting task (e.g., a smaller number of likes or followers immediately vs. a larger number of likes or followers later on). It was found that people tend to value future Instagram followers and likes less than immediate ones, especially smaller amounts (Schulz van Endert & Mohr, 2022).

    Delay discounting task for online followers; Schulz van Endert & Mohr, 2022.
    Delay discounting task for online followers; Schulz van Endert & Mohr, 2022. CC BY 4.0

    Environmental Outcomes

    Stimuli involving environmental outcomes have also been utilizes in order to capture decisions that involve immediate cost/effort for long-term environmental protection. The researchers could see if people were willing to pay a little now for a lot of environmental good later, or if they preferred to see the benefits sooner, even if they were smaller. For example, a smaller increase in carbon storage now (with a tax payment of ‘x’ today) vs. a significantly larger increase in carbon storage in 6 years (with a tax payment of ‘y’ in 6 years) (Grammatikopoulou et al., 2020).

    Health Outcomes

    These involve decisions with long-term health consequences and implications, such as medical procedures and treatment and even exercise and physical activity:

    Medical Procedures and Treatment

    In this context of delay discounting tasks, participants chose between immediate and delayed health scenarios.

    The stimuli involved in a study were different types of health outcomes, namely, “health boost” (an immediate temporary or short-term health enhancement) and a “cure” (a delayed long-term health improvement) (Friedel et al., 2016).

    Participants can be also be presented with choosing between immediate discomfort (e.g., undergoing a painful medical test now) and delayed health benefits (e.g., improved health outcomes after the test) (Talmi & Pine, 2012).

    Exercise and Physical Activity

    In a study using an exercise-focused delay discounting task, participants chose between exercising now or waiting for other rewards like money or food later. The results showed that exercise was valued less over time by people preferring to exercise immediately (particularly when it is self-paced) rather than delaying it for other rewards (Albelwi et al., 2019).


    Join Labvanced today and implement the delay discounting task in your next experiment.

    Educational and Career Outcomes

    Delay discounting tasks can also use stimuli that revolve around education and academic achievements for youth participants, or career outcomes for older participants.

    Academic Grades

    This includes immediate leisure vs. future better grades. A paper focused on the qualitative aspects of delay discounting in academic contexts rather than specific time-based quantities by presenting a general concept of immediate leisure activities and inherently delayed academic tasks (e.g., “watching a television show" vs. "successfully completing and submitting an assignment") (Olsen et al., 2018).

    Career Advancement

    In the concepts of career, immediate comfort vs. long-term career growth are considered. Students at the end of high school were presented with the decision of immediate comfort and long-term career growth (e.g., immediate work vs. continued academic studies) (Leitão et al., 2013).

    What is Labvanced?

    A powerful experiment-design platform (no coding required) with advanced features like webcam eye-tracking and more via web and native desktop/mobile applications.

    Sign Up


    Consumer Goods and Experiences

    Products serve as stimuli in delayed discounting tasks to study consumer preferences for immediate versus delayed gratification. For instance, in a study on consumer sales promotions, participants were presented with choices between immediate savings and delayed saving ($900 instant savings now vs. $1,000 rebate in 2 weeks) (Coker et al., 2010).

    Leisure activities and entertainmnet-related stimuli can also be used to quantify choices between immediate and delayed access to experiences. For example, participants might choose between paying $500 to attend a sporting event this weekend or waiting until next month to attend for free (Goodman et al., 2019).

    Conclusion

    The choice of stimulus depends heavily on the research question, the population being studied, and the real-world behaviors the researchers aim to understand. Using both monetary and non-monetary stimuli in the delay discounting task can provide more ecologically valid insights into specific decision-making contexts.

    References

    Albelwi, T. A., Rogers, R. D., & Kubis, H. P. (2019). Exercise as a reward: Self-paced exercise perception and delay discounting in comparison with food and money. Physiology & Behavior, 199, 333–342.

    Charlton, S. R., Gossett, B. D., & Charlton, V. A. (2012). Effect of delay and social distance on the perceived value of social interaction. Behavioural Processes, 89(1), 23–26.

    Coker, K. K., Pillai, D., & Balasubramanian, S. K. (2010). Delay‐discounting rewards from consumer sales promotions. Journal of Product & Brand Management, 19(7), 487–495.

    Friedel, J. E., DeHart, W. B., Frye, C. C., Rung, J. M., & Odum, A. L. (2016). Discounting of qualitatively different delayed health outcomes in current and never smokers. Experimental and Clinical Psychopharmacology, 24(1), 18.

    Goodman, J. K., Malkoc, S. A., & Rosenboim, M. (2019). The material-experiential asymmetry in discounting: When experiential purchases lead to more impatience. Journal of Consumer Research, 46(4), 671–688.

    Grammatikopoulou, I., Artell, J., Hjerppe, T., & Pouta, E. (2020). A mire of discount rates: delaying conservation payment schedules in a choice experiment. Environmental and Resource Economics, 77, 615–639.

    Lawyer, S. R. (2008). Probability and delay discounting of erotic stimuli. Behavioural Processes, 79, 36–42.

    Leitão, M., Guedes, Á., Yamamoto, M. E., & Lopes, F. D. A. (2013). Do people adjust career choices according to socioeconomic conditions? An evolutionary analysis of future discounting. Psychology & Neuroscience, 6(3), 383.

    Odum, A. L., Baumann, A. A., & Rimington, D. D. (2006). Discounting of delayed hypothetical money and food: Effects of amount. Behavioural processes, 73(3), 278-284.

    Odum, A. L., Becker, R. J., Haynes, J. M., Galizio, A., Frye, C. C., Downey, H., ... & Perez, D. M. (2020). Delay discounting of different outcomes: Review and theory. Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior, 113(3), 657-679.

    Olsen, R. A., Macaskill, A. C., & Hunt, M. J. (2018). A measure of delay discounting within the academic domain. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 31(4), 522–534.

    Petry, N. M. (2003). Discounting of money, health, and freedom in substance abusers and controls. Drug and Alcohol Dependence, 71(2), 133–141.

    Rasmussen, E. B., Camp, L., & Lawyer, S. R. (2024). The use of nonmonetary outcomes in health-related delay discounting research: Review and recommendations. Perspectives on Behavior Science, 47(2), 523–558.

    Schulz van Endert, T., & Mohr, P. N. (2022). Delay discounting of monetary and social media rewards: Magnitude and trait effects. Frontiers in Psychology, 13, 822505.

    Talmi, D., & Pine, A. (2012). How costs influence decision values for mixed outcomes. Frontiers in Neuroscience, 6, 146.

    Taylor, H., Smith, A. P., & Yi, R. (2023). Valuation of future alcohol in cross-commodity delay discounting is associated with alcohol misuse/consequences. Psychology of Addictive Behaviors, 37(1), 166.

    Weygandt, M., Mai, K., Dommes, E., Ritter, K., Leupelt, V., Spranger, J., & Haynes, J. D. (2015). Impulse control in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex counteracts post-diet weight regain in obesity. Neuroimage, 109, 318-327.